FAQFAQ   SearchSearch  MemberlistMemberlistRegisterRegister  ProfileProfile   Log in[ Log in ]  Flint Talk RSSFlint Talk RSS

»Home »Open Chat »Political Talk  »Flint Journal »Political Jokes »The Bob Leonard Show  

Flint Michigan online news magazine. We have lively web forums

FlintTalk.com Forum Index > Political Talk

Topic: Gretchen Whitmer files for Governor

  Author    Post Post new topic Reply to topic
El Supremo

Gretchen Whitmer
Fighter for Michigan. Former prosecutor and Senate Democratic leader. Proud mom.
23 mins ago
Im ready  are you?

Im no stranger to fights. As Ingham County Prosecutor and as Democratic leader in the Senate, Ive led a lot of tough ones. Fights to protect workers rights, fights to level the playing field for everyone, fights to protect kids and to hold government accountable.

No matter the outcome, the fight was always worth it for what it said to the people we were fighting for. To the men and women who dont know if they can count on their paycheck, to the students and their families taking on frightening amounts of college debt, to the women whose access to health care is threatened, to the brick and mortar business owner competing with the world on an unlevel playing field.

And it was worth it because it reinforced why I fight.

I love the state of Michigan. I love the people of Michigan. And when I was growing up, the opportunities in Michigan were the best in the world.

Opportunities to find and keep a good paying job, to build a business, to enjoy our land and drink pure, clean water, to create a future for our children. People moved to Michigan because we offered the best quality of life.

I remember when Michigan was bold. When we didnt just face challenges  we beat them. Thats why I know we can build a Michigan with opportunities that rival those from our past. A state where opportunities are available to every Michigander  regardless of gender or race or religion or who you love or where you were born  if you work hard and play by the rules.

And thats why, today, I filed the paperwork to run for Governor.

Together we can build the Michigan we believe in, because we still have what we need most  the strength, the talent, the vision and the grit of the incredible people of this state.

For too long, our leaders have been content to manage our decline. We went from leading the nation to lagging. If we want change, we cant wait for Washington to solve our problems. And we cant elect the same old politicians, on the same old platforms and expect a different result. We can do better. We deserve better.

And we cant wait. Too many people in Michigan need good-paying jobs, today. Right now, too many small business owners know the deck is stacked against them. Too many families cant trust that their government is looking out for their health and safety. Too many children arent prepared for their futures. And too many Michiganders face the threat of discrimination.

Its never been more critical to join the fight. Im ready  are you? Forward this email to five friends and find out how you can get involved at gretchenwhitmer.com.

Join me and well win this fight for Michigan.
Post Tue Jan 03, 2017 3:37 pm 
 View user's profile Send private message  Reply with quote  
El Supremo

Gretchen Whitmer to file for 2018 Michigan governor's race
Kathleen Gray , Detroit Free Press Lansing Bureau 2:48 p.m. EST January 3,
(Photo: Kimberly P. Mitchell, Detroit Free Press)

Former Senate Minority Leader Gretchen Whitmer will be the first candidate to officially jump into the 2018 election pool, by filing paperwork with the Secretary of State later today to set up a committee to run for governor.

It wasnt a big announcement or the beginning of a speaking tour around the state. Rather, filing the paperwork is a prerequisite for Whitmer if she wants to begin accepting contributions to her campaign.

A formal announcement by the East Lansing Democrat will come later this month, according to sources close to Whitmer.

2018 Michigan governor's election bubbles below surface at Mackinac

The filing is not a surprise. Whitmer has been saying for months that she plans to run to succeed Gov. Rick Snyder, an Ann Arbor Republican who cant run again because of term limits.

But she becomes the first of what will surely be a crowded field of candidates to fill an open gubernatorial seat. Other potential candidates are U.S. Rep. Dan Kildee, D-Flint, and Republicans Attorney General Bill Schuette, of Midland, and Lt. Gov. Brian Calley of Portland. All have said theyre contemplating a run for the seat.

Kildee will make a decision about the race in the coming months, said his spokesman Mitch Rivard.

"Congressman Kildee appreciates the encouragement he is getting from across the state to run for Governor. Right now, he is focused on representing his constituents in Congress, and in the coming months he will make a decision about where he can do the most good for Michigan families," he said in a statement.

Although shes been out of state office since 2015, after leaving the Senate because of term limits, Whitmer was appointed to fill the vacant Ingham County Prosecutors spot in May of 2016 through the end of the year after then Prosecutor Stuart Dunnings announced his resignation after being charged and ultimately convicted of soliciting prostitutes.

Whitmer also contemplated a run for Attorney General in 2009 and for Governor in 2013, but dropped those plans because of family concerns at the time.

Shes also been a fixture on the Democratic club circuit around the state, making appearances to Democratic Party and other progressive organizations across Michigan and speaking out consistently on social media.

The day after the Nov. 8 election, she wrote on Facebook, Today, I'm angry. But tomorrow, I am moving forward because I am more determined than ever to fight for a better Michigan that respects one another, that celebrates our differences while valuing our shared strengths, and believes that each and every one of us deserves the opportunity to succeed.

Whitmer is a former state Representative, serving from 2001-2006 when she ran to fill a vacancy created by then Sen. Virg Bernero, who left his seat to become Mayor of Lansing. She served in the Senate from 2006-2014, where she became a frequent and loud voice of opposition to Republican policies.

When she told her personal story of being raped more than 20 years ago during a 2013 speech on the Senate floor to illustrate her opposition to a bill that would require people to buy an additional rider to their insurance to get an abortion covered, Whitmer got national attention and a stronger voice on issues surrounding womens health concerns.

Contact Kathleen Gray: 313-223-4430, kgray99@freepress.com or on Twitter @michpoligal
Post Tue Jan 03, 2017 3:45 pm 
 View user's profile Send private message  Reply with quote  
El Supremo

This is an important article that gets to the heart of why Betsy DeVos wants to dismantle our public schools. She laments that public schools have displaced the Church as the center of communities, and cites school choice as a way to reverse that trend. Anyone who supports public schools should vehemently oppose DeVos as education secretary.
Trump's education pick says reform can 'advance God's Kingdom'
Betsy DeVos shares the religious beliefs that drive her activism in a 2001 interview.
Post Mon Jan 16, 2017 4:05 pm 
 View user's profile Send private message  Reply with quote  
El Supremo

How Betsy DeVos Used God and Amway to Take Over Michigan Politics

With her nomination as education secretary, a powerful political clan will bring its overtly Christian agenda to Washington.

By Zack Stanton

January 15, 2017

On election night 2006, Dick DeVos, the bronzed, starched 51-year-old scion of Michigans wealthiest family, paced to a lectern in the dim ballroom of the Sheraton Hotel in Lansing to deliver the speech that every candidate dreads.

The Michigan gubernatorial race that year had been a dogfight of personal attacks between DeVos, the Republican nominee, and Democratic Governor Jennifer Granholm. Gloomy, bleached-out b-roll of shuttered factories in anti-Granholm ads made the governors sunny economic promise that Youre gonna be blown away sound less like an aspiration than a threat. Anti-DeVos ads cut closer to the bone, with one depicting a cartoon DeVos cheering a freighter hauling Michigan jobs to China. It was an unsubtle reference to DeVos time as president of Amway, the direct-sales behemoth his family co-founded and co-owns, when he eliminated jobs in Michigan while expanding dramatically in Asia. DeVos ended up personally spending $35 million on the racethe most expensive campaign in Michigan historyand when the votes came in, lost by a crushing 14 points.

At the Lansing Sheraton, the mood was grim. If we arent going to be able to serve in this way, I look forward to the ways we can, DeVos told his glum supporters. Behind him on the ballroom risers stood his family; closest to him was his wife, Betsy, choking back tears.

Though dressed in a blue skirt-suit, the uniform of a first ladyship that was not to be, Betsy DeVos was never a political accessory. Anyone who understood Michigan politics knew she had long been the more political animal of the pair. It was Betsy, not Dick, who had chaired the Michigan Republican Party; Betsy, who had served as a member of the Republican National Committee; Betsy, whose name was once floated to succeed Haley Barbour as head of the RNC; Betsy, who had directed a statewide ballot campaign to legalize public funding of religious schools; Betsy, who, as a college freshman, traveled to Ohio and Indiana to volunteer for Gerald Fords presidential campaign. She was a skilled and seasoned operator, but as her husband conceded in an overwhelming defeat, she was utterly helpless.

At the time, it seemed like a dead end for a neophyte political candidate. In reality, it was the opening of a new avenue the DeVoses followed to far greater political influence, reshaping Michigan politics and the national Republican scene. I think that loss really solidified the idea in the DeVoses minds that the real way to get what you want is to be behind the scenes, says Susan Demas, publisher of Inside Michigan Politics.

In the decade since that loss, the DeVos family, with Dick and Betsy at the helm, has emerged as a political force without comparison in Michigan. Their politics are profoundly Christian and conservativeGod, America, Free Enterprise, to borrow the subtitle of family patriarch Richard DeVos 1975 book, Believe!and their vast resources (the familys cumulative net worth is estimated at well over $5 billion) assure that they can steamroll their way to victory on issues ranging from education reform to workers rights. At the federal level, when GOP candidates are looking for big donors to back them, they have options, says Craig Mauger, executive director of the Michigan Campaign Finance Network. If you dont get Sheldon Adelson, you can go to the Koch brothers, and so on. In Michigan, the DeVos family is a class of donor all by themselves.
Top: Gubernatorial candidate Dick DeVos shakes hands while campaigning with wife Betsy and Arizona Senator John McCain. Bottom left: Betsy DeVos and President George H.W. Bush at a 2000 campaign fundraiser for George W. Bush. Bottom right: In 2004, Betsy DeVos campaigns with Representatives Mike Rogers and Candice Miller.

Top: Gubernatorial candidate Dick DeVos shakes hands while campaigning with wife Betsy and Arizona Senator John McCain. Bottom left: Betsy DeVos and President George H.W. Bush at a 2000 campaign fundraiser for George W. Bush. Bottom right: In 2004, Betsy DeVos campaigns with Representatives Mike Rogers and Candice Miller. | Regina H. Boone/TNS/ZUMAPRESS.com; AP Photos

Thanks to the DeVoses, Michigans charter schools enjoy a virtually unregulated existence. Thanks to them, too, the center of the American automotive industry and birthplace of the modern labor movement is now a right-to-work state. Theyve funded campaigns to elect state legislators, established advocacy organizations to lobby them, buttressed their allies and primaried those they disagree with, spending at least $100 million on political campaigns and causes over the past 20 years. The DeVos family has been far more successful not having the governors seat than if they had won it, says Richard Czuba, the owner of the Glengariff Group, a bipartisan polling firm in Michigan. They have, to some degree, created a shadow state party. And its been pretty darn effective.

Buoyed by the success in Michigan, the DeVoses have exported a scaled-down version of that template into other states, funding an archipelago of local political action committees and advocacy organizations to ease the proliferation of charter schools in Indiana, New Jersey, Ohio, Iowa, Virginia and Louisiana, among others. At the same time, DeVos-backed PACs have transformed the nature of American political campaigns. By showing the success of independent PACs that answered to a few deep-pocketed donors rather than a broad number of stakeholders associated with a union or chamber of commerce, for instance, the DeVoses precipitated the monsoon of independent expenditures that has rained down upon politicians for the past decade. In the process, theyve reshaped political campaigns as well as the policies that result from them.

Ten years after she watched her husband give a concession speech, Betsy DeVos was unveiled as President-elect Donald Trumps pick for secretary of education. Across the country, public-school advocates and teachers unions expressed almost unanimous horror: One of the most effective advocates for breaking down the rules and protections for public schools and teachers would soon be the nations most powerful education policymaker.

But people whove been watching the DeVoses closely knew they were seeing something else as well: One of the nations most ambitious, disruptive and downright unusual political families finally had a seat in Washington.


To understand the DeVos family, it helps to understand West Michigan. A sweeping landscape of flat, rolling farmland freckled with small towns, it sits on the opposite side of the statein more than one wayfrom the big, diverse, reliably Democratic Detroit metropolitan area. Broadly speaking, its a region where people are deeply religious, politically conservative, entrepreneurial and unfailingly politethink Utah, if it were settled not by Mormons but by Dutch Calvinists. Theres an old expression here, chuckles Gleaves Whitney, director of the Hauenstein Center for Presidential Studies at Grand Valley State University in Grand Rapids. If you aint Dutch, you aint much.

The DeVos family is Dutch, thoroughly so. All four of Richard DeVos grandparents emigrated from the Netherlands, and today, the family continues to observe the tenets of the Christian Reformed Church, a Calvinist denomination. Calvinism believes that God has decided our souls fates before we are born, assigning them to heaven or hell. It is a duty of practitioners to show their faith in Gods plan by displaying self-confidence, as though they know they have been chosen for blessings in the afterlife. One way to display this confidence is through entrepreneurship (one of the bedrock texts of sociology, Max Webers 1905 Protestant Work Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, is expressly about the link between Calvinism and economic success).

In this, Dick and Betsy DeVos familial roots serve as an object example. Dick is the eldest son of Richard DeVos, who co-founded Amway in 1959, and grew it from a meager soap factory into a multinational colossus with $9.5 billion in annual sales, enlisting his children to manage and expand the company. Betsy hails from a dynasty of her own. In 1965, her father, Edgar Prince, founded a small manufacturing company that came to be worth more than $1 billion on the strength of Princes automotive innovations, which include the pull-down sun visor with a built-in light-up vanity mirror.

When Betsy Prince and Dick DeVos married in 1979, it brought together two powerful Dutch families with perfectly compatible values. Theres a close-knit atmosphere of the aristocracy of West Michigan, Demas says. It almost brings to mind the old monarchies of Europe where they would intermarry.

Theres a close-knit atmosphere of the aristocracy of West Michigan, Demas says. It almost brings to mind the old monarchies of Europe where they would intermarry.

Amway, the machine that built the DeVos fortune, is among the best-known multilevel-marketing companies in the world, relying on independent salespeople to start their own businesses selling Amway-produced goods and to recruit other independent salespeople to work underneath them. Over the past half-century, the company has attracted a healthy dose of criticism. In 1969, the Federal Trade Commission alleged that Amway was a pyramid scheme, launching a six-year investigation that failed to prove the charges. In 1982, the government of Canada filed criminal charges against the company, alleging that Amway had defrauded the country out of $28 million in customs duties and forged fake receipts to cover its tracks; in November 1983, Amway pled guilty to fraud and Canadian prosecutors dropped the criminal charges against Richard DeVos and other company executives. Amways direct-sales modelwhich it has exported to more than 100 countrieshas become a ubiquitous part of the modern economy. (Among those who've experimented with the approach is the president-elect, whose Trump Network in 2009 used an Amway-esque sales pitch to recruit sellers of nutritional supplements, snack foods and skin-care products.)

In Western Michigan, what matters isnt how Amway is run, but what the DeVoses have done for the community. Drive through downtown Grand Rapids, Michigans second-largest metropolis, and the familys contributions are omnipresent. Theres the Helen DeVos Childrens Hospital. A few blocks west, hugging the Grand River that bisects the city, youll find the sleek DeVos Place Convention Center, the DeVos Performance Hall and the Amway Grand Plaza Hotel. Across the water, the campus of Grand Valley State University is anchored by the spacious Richard M. DeVos Center. A few blocks north is the DeVos Learning Center, housed at the Gerald R. Ford Presidential Museum. (You would be forgiven if you assumed that DeVos, not Ford, had been president.)

Today, the DeVoses charitable giving and local boosterism mean that people in West Michigan have a different view of them than Michiganders elsewhere in the state. The political narrative that has grown around [the family] is unfair, says Whitney, whose Hauenstein Center has received grant funding from the DeVos Family Foundation. They have made life better for a lot of people, and I cant say that loudly enough.
The first and second generations of the DeVos family. Leftright: Dick & Betsy, Cheri, Helen & Richard, Daniel & Pamella and Doug & Maria.

The first and second generations of the DeVos family. Leftright: Dick & Betsy, Cheri, Helen & Richard, Daniel & Pamella and Doug & Maria. | Credit: Orlando Magic Media Guide

The DeVos familys charitable giving and political activism sprawls across three generations. Its not just Dick and Betsy, but Richard and Helens other children, too. Theres Daniel DeVos, who chairs the Orlando Magic, an NBA franchise the family owns, and his wife, Pamella. Theres Doug DeVos, Amways current president and the chair of the executive committee of the National Constitution Center, and his wife, Maria. Theres Cheri DeVos, who sits on the board at Alticor, Amways parent company. And theres their children, a generation of young adults ready to carry the baton.

Over time, the DeVos clan has evolved an unusual and highly structured internal governance system. Family patriarch Richard DeVos, now 90 and retired from an active role in Amway, explained the formal structure of this family government in his 2014 book, Simply Rich:

We formed the DeVos Family Council, which is made up of our children and their spouses and meets four times a year. The Family Council just approved a family constitution that essentially captures our family mission and values. The Family Council also articulates how the family will work together in managing our shared financial interests and our philanthropy.

We also have the Family Assembly . When grandchildren turn 16, they are inducted in a formal ceremony that everyone attends. An aunt or uncle makes a presentation of their achievements, reminds them of their responsibility as they go forward, and affirms them as a member of the Family Assembly. They are able to vote in the meetings at age 25, after they have met additional qualifications for taking on this added responsibility.

This collective approach is how the family runs their home lives, too. The DeVoses myriad properties are managed through a single private company, RDV Corporation, which both manages the familys investments and operates as a home office, paying the familys employees, maintaining the DeVoses residences and assuring them as frictionless a life as possible. (The duties outlined by one recent property-manager job with RDV Corporation include ensur[ing] doors are well-oiled to avoid squeaking and that broken toys [are] repaired or disposed of.)

This family-government approach has so far enabled the DeVos family to avoid the public schisms and disagreements that have plagued other multigenerational dynasties. Any dissent is hashed out in private, and that enables the family to focus its collective efforts with the precision of a scalpel and the power of a chainsaw. If youre a politician who wins the familys support, youll receive several maxed-out checks from multiple family members, all in a bundle.

Across those efforts, one constant is the DeVos familys devout Christian beliefs, and the indivisibility they see between Christian and Calvinistic notions and their conservative politics. The real strength of America is its religious tradition, Richard DeVos wrote in Believe!. Too many people today are willing to act as if God had nothing whatsoever to do with it. This country was built on a religious heritage, and wed better get back to it. We had better start telling people that faith in God is the real strength of America! In the mid-1970s, DeVos made major donations to the Christian Freedom Foundation and Third Century Publishers, an outlet that printed books and pamphlets designed to strengthen the ties between Christianity and free-market conservatism; among those products was a guidebook instructing conservative Christians how to win elections and help America become as it was when first foundeda Christian Republic.
Clockwise, from upper left: Amway cofounders Jay Van Andel (left) and Richard DeVos (center) meet in the Oval Office with President Gerald Ford, who is holding a copy of Richards book, Believe!; former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush and Richard DeVos during a 2009 event at the Scripps Research Institute; an aerial shot of Dick & Betsy DeVoss primary residence in Ada, Michigan; Dick & Betsy enjoy their courtside seats at an Orlando Magic gamean NBA team owned by the DeVos family.

Clockwise, from upper left: Amway cofounders Jay Van Andel (left) and Richard DeVos (center) meet in the Oval Office with President Gerald Ford, who is holding a copy of Richards book, Believe!; former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush and Richard DeVos during a 2009 event at the Scripps Research Institute; an aerial shot of Dick & Betsy DeVoss primary residence in Ada, Michigan; Dick & Betsy enjoy their courtside seats at an Orlando Magic gamean NBA team owned by the DeVos family. | National Archives; AP; Getty Images

Though they arent quite as large or wealthy as the DeVoses, the Prince familyeven further west, in Holland, Michiganshares one big trait in common with their in-laws: the idea that patriotism and politics are inseparable from Christianity. Elsa Prince Broekhuizen, Betsys mother, donated $75,000 to the successful 2004 ballot measure to ban same-sex marriage in Michigan; four years later, she gave $450,000 to an identical initiative in California. Betsys brother, Erik Prince, founded Blackwater, the military contractor that gained notoriety in 2007, when its employees fired into a crowd of Iraqi civilians, killing 17. (In 2009, two former Blackwater employees alleged in federal court that Prince views himself as a Christian crusader.)

Throughout his adult life, Betsys father, Ed, donated handsomely to two religious colleges in Michigan, Hope and Calvin, the latter being his wifes beloved alma mater in Grand Rapids. But his most important contributionone that has shaped much of the past three decades of conservative politicscame in 1988, when Prince donated millions in seed funding to launch the Family Research Council, the conservative Christian group that became one of the most potent political forces on the religious right. Ed Prince was not an empire builder, Family Research Council President Gary Bauer wrote to supporters after Princes sudden death in 1995. He was a Kingdom builder.

In the 1960s and 70s, Ed and Elsa Prince advanced Gods Kingdom from the end of a cul-de-sac just a few miles from Lake Michigan. There, they taught their four childrenElisabeth (Betsy), Eileen, Emilie and Erika deeply religious, conservative, free-market view of the world, emphasizing the importance of self-reliance and sending them to private schools that would reinforce the values they celebrated at home, small-government conservatism chief among them.

Ed Prince was not an empire builder, Family Research Council President Gary Bauer wrote after Princes death in 1995. He was a Kingdom builder.

In a breakfast speech to volunteers at Holland Christian Schools on May 12, 1975, Ed Prince warned that lazy and neglectful U.S. citizens were not doing their fair share, forcing the government to, as a Holland Sentinel article described it, play an increasingly larger role in our daily and personal lives. (You dont have to listen too hard to hear an echo of Ed Prince in his daughter, Betsy. [For welfare recipients] to sit and be handed money from the government because they think a job like that is beneath them, the heiress sighed to the Detroit Free Press in 1992. If I had to work on a line in a factory, I would do that before I would stand in line for a welfare check.)

From an early age, Betsy was pushed to compete. In 1965, she was one of two second-graders to make entries in Hollands annual tulip festival (a citywide valentine to the areas Dutch heritage). In middle school, she entered a poster and essay contest about crime prevention. In her teenage years, she was a member of the Holland City Recreation Swim Team. Betsy excelled at the breaststroke. In August 1972, she won the Mid-Michigan Conference Championship, a contest in which younger siblings Emilie and Eileen Prince placed third and fifth, respectively).

After graduating from high school in 1975, Betsy enrolled at Calvin College, her mothers alma mater. Calvins mission, as stated in the 19751976 course catalog, was to prepare students to live productive lives of faith to the glory of God in contemporary societynot merely lives that have a place for religion but lives which in every part, in every manifestation, in their very essence, are Christian.

On campus, Betsy became politically active, volunteering for the presidential campaign of hometown hero President Gerald Ford, who was facing off against movie star-cum-California Governor Ronald Reagan. She joined a pro-Ford group called Friends of the First Family, and along with her compatriots, took trips to Indiana and Ohio to participate in the Ford campaigns scatter blitzes.

Betsys campaigning earned the attention of the Ford team, which tapped her to attend that year's Republican National Convention in Kansas City as a participant in the Presidentials program for young Republicans. The budding politicos attended training on campaign strategy and political techniques, and were divided into groups based on geography so that they could get acquainted with potential allies from their home states. There were also more practical desires for a squadron of young volunteers at a contested convention: Anywhere there needed to be noise, there were always kids, Betsy Prince told a reporter for the Holland Sentinel in 1976 (Betsy Helps Cheer Ford Through in Kansas City, read the headline, beside a photo of a T-shirt-clad Betsy sporting a feathered, Farrah Fawcett-lite hairdo).

Around this time, Betsy Prince met the two men with whom she would form the most important political relationships of her adult life. One became her husband; the other became her governor.


If theres one law of physics that defined how Michigan politics moved in the 1990s, its that Governor John Engler was a master of the state Legislature. His political acumenhoned over a 20-year run in the Legislature, during which the 22-year-old boy wonder grew into his sturdy tree-stump physique and Ben Franklin hairlinewas legendary even before he won a stunning upset in the 1990 governors race.

Never was that mastery more evident than on July 19, 1993, a date that set into motion every battle over education the state has seen sincea day that led to Betsy DeVos becoming Donald Trumps pick for secretary of education.

Deep into his first term, Engler wanted to show progress in his signature proposal to reduce the states onerous property taxes by 20 percent. Property taxes being the funding source for Michigans public school system, Democrats ruled out any plan that did not include a replacement for the lost revenue, and since any new revenue would require legislators to vote for new taxes or fees, that option had little appeal heading into the 1994 campaign. On July 19, 1993, Democratic state Senator Debbie Stabenow proposed an amendment that was interpreted as an attempt to point out the absurdity of Englers plan: Why not cut them by 100 percent without having any replacement revenue source?

Democrats were dumbstruck by what happened next: Engler whipped the state Legislature into action, and in the course of a 24-hour period, the Senate and House eradicated property taxesin the process completely defunding Michigans $6.5 billion public-education system. In the ensuing crisis, Engler legalized charter schools.
Throughout the 1990s, Republican Governor John Engler was a force without parallel in Michigan politics.

Throughout the 1990s, Republican Governor John Engler was a force without parallel in Michigan politics. | AP Photos

By that point, Betsy DeVos was already a major Engler backershe had served as the GOP chair in powerful Kent County, and in 1992, won one of the states seats on the RNC, ousting Ronna Romney (sister-in-law of Mitt Romney and mother of Ronna Romney McDaniel, whom Trump has chosen to helm the RNC). But education reform had long been a passion, and now she had an opportunity to help the governor who was enacting the changes she so badly wanted.

In May 1996, the chair of the Michigan Republican Party stepped down to run for Congress. John Engler had just the person for the job. Betsy DeVos accepted, and the following year, decided to run for a full term as party chair.

If Engler thought he had anointed a rubber stamp, he quickly learned otherwise. In January 1997, DeVos cleared house, unilaterally firing all of the partys top directors and pausing all contracts with vendors, blaming them for the partys losses months earlier. Betsy regarded the governors input as good advice, not an order, Greg McNeilly, a close associate of Betsy DeVos, told an Engler biographer years later. Thats when the problems started.

After an enormously successful 1998 campaign wherein Engler won a third and final term in a landslide, the governor encouraged Betsy DeVos to run for chair of the RNC. DeVos had a different battle in mind: a statewide campaign to legalize school vouchers.

The Michigan state constitution expressly forbids public funds from being used to pay for private, religious schools. Betsy DeVos aimed to change that via a constitutional amendmentProposal 1 on the November 2000 ballots.

Engler was opposed to the ideathe timing was off. I was pretty certain that it was premature to go to the ballot in 2000, Engler says, because if youre going to go to the ballot, you want to win. The DeVoses had counted on his support, and when it didnt materialize, things soured. ([John Engler] would have a hard time being a first mate even on the largest ship in the world, Betsy DeVos later wrote. I think hed sooner be captain of a smaller boat than the first mate on a much bigger ship.)

DeVos quickly realized that the situation was unsustainable. So she hatched a plan designed to surprise Engler just as his opposition had surprised her: She would resign as state GOP chair without notifying him in advance. She chose a date in February 2000 when she knew Engler would be in Washington. Around 9 a.m., she left a message on his phone, informing him that she would announce her resignation at an early-afternoon news conference. Engler quickly changed his itinerary and booked a flight home for his own news conference that evening. Publicly, Engler saved face, but the message from the DeVoses was unmistakable: We are a political force with our own agenda, like it or not.

The message from the DeVoses was unmistakable: We are a political force with our own agenda, like it or not.

Now, however, the DeVoses were on their own, pushing Prop 1 with minimal support from the states Republican establishment. Among the broader public, the opposition was fierce and widespread. That was one of the best campaigns I was ever on, says Julie Matuzak, who was, at the time, the American Federation of Teachers top political hand in the state.

While the DeVoses campaigned on expanding educational choices for parents and students, their opponents reframed the issue. When you really looked at it, the parents werent the ones with the choices; the parochial schools were the ones with the choices, Matuzak remembers. If all you do is transfer the money, you don't transfer any of the other requirements that are put on public schools. Public schools are required to take everyone who comes through the door. But private schools, parochial schools, get to pick and choose. Its not really the parents who have the choice, its the schools. And people ultimately understood that.

When Election Day came, the result was overwhelming: Proposal 1 failed with 69 percent of voters opposed. Across the spectrum, political observers viewed the initiative as a debacle that drove up Democratic turnout and likely cost Republicans a U.S. Senate seat, as Debbie Stabenow defeated incumbent Senator Spencer Abraham by 67,000 votes.

There was a silver lining for the DeVoses, albeit one not immediately apparent. They had established a purity test for fellow Republicans: Had they supported Prop 1? And in unintentionally contributing to Senator Abrahams loss, they had created a scenario in which, once Engler was term-limited in January 2003, the state GOP would be without any marquee statewide officeholders. No governor. Neither U.S. senator. An attorney general and secretary of state without any previous statewide experience.

There was a power vacuum in the Republican Party, and the DeVoses were the only ones who could fill it. Which they did, with lots and lots of money.


When Dick and Betsy DeVos are asked why theyve chosen to mount a personal crusade for education reform, they often cite their familys charitable giving, which puts them into contact with scholarship applicants. For years, the DeVoses read reams of personal essays filled with wrenching stories of dire finances and an abiding hope in the transformative impact of education. Those stories, the DeVoses have said, made it clear that something had to change.

But theres another reason why Dick and Betsy DeVos want to change Americas schools. They see it as the literal battleground for making a more Christian, God-centered society.

In 2001, Betsy DeVos spoke at The Gathering, an annual meeting of some of Americas wealthiest Christians. There, she told her fellow believers about the animating force behind her education-reform campaigning, referencing the biblical battlefield where the Israelites fought the Philistines: It goes back to what I mentioned, the concept of really being active in the Shephelah of our cultureto impact our culture in ways that are not the traditional funding-the-Christian-organization route, but that really may have greater Kingdom gain in the long run by changing the way we approach thingsin this case, the system of education in the country.

Dick DeVos, on stage with his wife, echoed her sentiments with a lament of his own. The churchwhich ought to be, in our view, far more central to the life of the communityhas been displaced by the public school, Dick DeVos said. We just can think of no better way to rebuild our families and our communities than to have that circle of church and school and family much more tightly focused and built on a consistent worldview.

For the DeVoses, an electoral losseven an embarrassing oneis but a small skirmish on that Shephelah. Prop 1s failure was evidence that they needed to redraw their battle plans for a much larger war.

Betsy DeVos stressed that Christians need to focus on greater Kingdom gain by changing the system of education in the country.

Dick DeVos echoed that: As the center of the community, The church has been displaced by the public school.

They unveiled the new strategy in 2001, the same year they spoke at The Gathering: Instead of direct appeals to voters, the DeVoses would devote their resources to PACs and nonprofit organizations to push legislators to enact the changes they desired. Thus, the Great Lakes Education Project, or GLEP, was founded.

Initially, few in Michigan knew quite what to make of GLEP. At the time, most PACs were affiliated with membership organizations, like a labor union or chamber of commerce, and focused on issues important to those members. GLEP wasnt anything like that. It was a largely family-funded effort with a singular focus on education reform; a multipronged structure gave GLEP great latitude to advocate, from lobbying legislators to purchasing attack ads on TV.

In the years since the DeVoses debuted GLEP, weve witnessed the nationwide rise of single-issue PACs funded by a small number of extraordinarily wealthy donors, especially since the Citizens United ruling uncorked the dam of corporate money. The [DeVos] family has been forward-thinking in their use of money to influence politics, says Craig Mauger of the Michigan Campaign Finance Network. And whats happening with them in Michigan seems to be an example of where were going as a country with the concentration of power in our politics.
Betsy DeVos has pushed a drastic transformation of Michigans education system, with mixed and controversial results.

Betsy DeVos has pushed a drastic transformation of Michigans education system, with mixed and controversial results.

In 2002, the first election of GLEPs existence, its PAC had more money than the Michigan Education Association, United Auto Workers, or any Democratic-affiliated PAC in the state. And if they lacked the influence and statewide presence of those groups, it was only a matter of time. They take a very long-term view, says Matuzak. If you pick up a few new Republican legislators every two years, and throw a fair amount of money at legislators who are already there, you can create coalitions of folks who can tackle what seem to be impossibly large issues.

It was the lesson of John Englers governorship: If you want to get things done, control the state Legislature. But you cant get that without inspiring some degree of fear.

One Republican who caught the DeVos familys ire was Paul Muxlow, a realtor and former educator elected to the state house in 2010, representing a mostly rural district in southeast Michigan. Muxlow was a dependable conservative, but disliked the idea of eliminating the cap on the number of charter schools. While he was fine with charter schools in underserved communities, he said he couldnt support them in rural areasIt would kill those districts, he explained to the Detroit Free Press in 2014. When the cap elimination came before the state Legislature in 2011, it passed with Muxlow voting against it. The following year, when he ran for reelection, he faced a blitz of attacks from GLEP, which didnt even need his district, but spent just under $185,000 to take him out in the primary. Muxlow won by just 132 votes.

Privately, many Michigan Republicans are afraid of getting on the DeVoses bad side. At the American Federation of Teachers, there were always Republicans wed endorse, recalls Matuzak, who retired from the union in 2014. And it got to the point where the Republicans would say, Please dont endorse me because it will hurt me with the DeVoses. Theyd send back money because the DeVoses would punish them. (In an email to POLITICO, the chief of staff to one Republican state senator declined comment for this story, saying it would not be productive before linking to two anti-DeVos columns in the Detroit Free Press. The articles speak for themselves, he wrote.)

The Republicans would say, Please dont endorse me because it will hurt me with the DeVoses. Theyd send back money because the DeVoses would punish them.

Theres a general awareness if theyre not supporting you, says John Truscott, a longtime Republican operative in Michigan and the president of Truscott-Rossman, a powerhouse bipartisan PR firm that represents the DeVos family on certain matters. If youre always getting along with everybody, youre probably not making a difference.

Year by year, cycle by cycle, the DeVoses built a state Legislature in their own image. By the time Democrat Jennifer Granholm was term-limited in 2010 and Republican Rick Snyder was elected governor without any political experience, it was the DeVoses, not Snyder, who knew how to get things done. Unlike the Engler years, this time, they had more sway than the governor.

Today, 16 years after the DeVoses failed constitutional amendment, this constant push has totally remade Michigan education. The cap on the number of charter schools eliminated and attempts to provide public oversight have been defeated, making Michigans charters among the most-plentiful and least-regulated in the nation. About 80 percent of Michigans 300 publicly funded charters are operated by for-profit companies, more than any other state. This means that taxpayer dollars that would otherwise go to traditional public schools are instead used to buy supplies such as textbooks and desks that become private property. It is, essentially, a giant experiment in what happens when you shift resources away from public schools.

And while a state constitutional amendment legalizing public funding for religious schools is unlikely to win public support anytime soon, charters have had much the same impact. While a charter school cannot be religiously affiliated, many walk a fine line, appointing, for instance, a preacher as head of the school board or renting school space from a church. They have a couple ways of getting around it, says Gary Miron, a professor of education at Western Michigan University who specializes in charter school evaluation and research. Ive been in charter schools where Ive seen religious prayers to Jesus Christthey mention Christ by nameand prayer circles with students, teachers and parents.

For students, the results of the Michigan charter boom have been mixed. Most charters perform below the states averages on tests, even while their enrollment has grown to include more than 110,000 students, nearly half of whom live in the Detroit area. A 2013 Stanford study that compared Detroits charters with its traditional public schools found that the charter students gained the equivalent of more than three months learning per year more than their counterparts at traditional public schools. But that doesnt mean theyre performing at a high level, simply that by some measures, certain charters marginally outperform the historically challenged Detroit public schools.

Whatever the quality outcome, the political lesson isnt lost. The DeVoses have transplanted their organizational model to other statesNew Jersey, Ohio, Louisiana, Virginia, Wisconsin, among them. They have done this by marshaling forces under the umbrella of their American Federation for Children, a nationwide campaign for school reform that has attracted high-profile speakers to its conferences, including New Jersey Senator Cory Booker, former Governor Bobby Jindal, New Jersey Governor Chris Christie and former D.C. school czar Michelle Rhee.


In the transformation of Michigan from a blue-collar Rust Belt Democratic stronghold to a free-market, Republican conquest, no issue may be more symbolic than the enactment of right-to-work legislation.

On its face, the debate over right-to-work is about an arcane bit of labor lawwhether workers under a contract that was collectively negotiated by a union should have to pay dues to that union, regardless of whether theyre members. But that debate is a proxy for a larger battle that is less about employment law than political jockeying: Unions tends to align with Democrats, and as a result, if it becomes more difficult for unions to collect dues, theyll be weakened and less able to advocate for the political causes of their choosing.

Days after the 2012 election, Dick DeVos picked up the phone and rallied Republican lawmakers to pass right-to-work in lame duck while they still had the votes, reportedly promising financial support to those members who would find themselves facing tough reelections and suggesting he would back primary campaigns against those who didnt step in line. Theres one family who gets these people elected, and consequently, you can assume they can get them unelected, too, says Gretchen Whitmer, who was the state Senates Democratic leader at the time.

Theres one family who gets these people elected, and consequently, you can assume they can get them unelected, too, says Gretchen Whitmer, the former Democratic leader of the state senate.

To opponents, right to work ran counter to every story Michigan told itself about who it was, a repudiation of generations of hard-won gains. In metro Detroit, labors historic triumphs are retold like folklore by men with thick, calloused hands, lest future generations forget the Battle of the Overpass or the Flint Sit-Down Strike. Right-to-work, labor feared, would undo much of that.

Though anxious, labor officials had reason to feel confident. On November 26, 2012, the Monday after Thanksgiving, Republican Governor Rick Snyder had reassured them that right-to-work was not on my agenda. The impression we had from the beginning was the governor wanted to keep this thing off his desk, Steven Cook, president of the Michigan Education Association, said at the time.

Over the course of a few days in late November and early December, everything changed. Perhaps it had something to do with the $1.8 million blitz of TV and radio ads promoting right-to-work the DeVoses bankrolled.

On December 6, eight days after Snyder met with labor leaders, the governor flipped on the issue, announcing his intent to sign right-to-work into law. The day it became apparent, he wasnt returning phone calls from any of us, remembers Whitmer.
Protesters in and around the state capitol in Lansing on December 11, 2012. "Governor 4 Sale, read one sign. Call 1-800-Dick-DeVos.

Protesters in and around the state capitol in Lansing on December 11, 2012. "Governor 4 Sale, read one sign. Call 1-800-Dick-DeVos. | AP Photo/Paul Sancya

The next five days saw large protests on the Capitol grounds, culminating with an estimated 12,500 demonstrators on December 11, the day the House voted on the legislation. Two-thousand demonstrators flooded into the Capitol, sitting in the hallways and laying down in the rotunda. They stomped their feet, chanted familiar slogans, sang Solidarity Forevera cacophony that some in the House chamber one story up initially confused for thunder.

Right-to-work passed by a handful of votes, including an Engler-esque flourish: The legislation was amended to include a small appropriation, which meant that once signed, it would be impossible for voters to repeal by public referendum.

Outside the Capitol, state police donned riot gear while officers on horseback pushed protesters away from the building. Loudspeakers blared Tom Pettys I Wont Back Down, and as the wind picked up, four 20-foot-tall inflatable rat balloons skittered from side to side. Each rat represented one of the key players protesters blamed for right-to-works hasty adoption: the governor, the House speaker, the Senate majority leader, andthe only unelected member of the rat packDick DeVos.

It isnt known what, if anything, the DeVoses said to Governor Snyder to change his mind and detonate this atomic bomb in Michigan politics. But Snyder wouldve been under no illusions about the possible consequences of inaction. There was all kinds of scuttlebutt that if Snyder didn't sign up for right-to-work in 2012, he wouldve bought himself a primary in 2014, says Demas of Inside Michigan Politics. I think Snyder understands the powerful place the DeVoses have in Michigan, and that its often more trouble than its worth to tangle with them.


In the weeks since Donald Trump announced that he would nominate DeVos for secretary of education, Michigans political circles have been abuzz. As ever, the DeVoses are loved and hated, with little in between. She is a strong supporter of public education and of quality education for every child, says Engler. Its horrifying. Its a slap in the face, says Whitmer. The only people who have anything to worry about are those running failing schools, says Truscott. It is as if you were to appoint some radical pacifist as secretary of defense, says Jack Lessenberry, a senior political analyst for Michigan Public Radio.

After years operating behind the scenes, Betsy DeVos is set to become the public face of education policy in Americaan advocate of private Christian education helming the largest public-education agency in the country. Most education policymaking happens at the state and local level; the Education Department administers financial aid and collects and analyzes educational data, but doesnt set state standards or school curricula. Even so, the position is a considerable bully pulpit, one with the ability to define the national discussion on education.
Donald Trump applauds as Betsy DeVos speaks at Trumps Thank You USA rally in Grand Rapids, December 9, 2016.

Donald Trump applauds as Betsy DeVos speaks at Trumps Thank You USA rally in Grand Rapids, December 9, 2016. | Reuters/Mike Segar

As secretary, its likely DeVos will pursue a national expansion of school choice and charters. In this, DeVos has an ally in President-elect Trump. There's no failed policy more in need of urgent change than our government-run education monopoly, Trump said in a September 8 speech. It is time to break up that monopoly. In that speech, Trump proposed a $20-billion block grant program to fund national vouchers administered at the state level. Parents will be able to send their kids to the desired public, private or religious school of their choice, Trump said.

Its what Betsy DeVos has wanted all along.

Barring a surprise at confirmation hearings, the DeVos family will soon have a seat in Washington. But a question lingers: Will they continue as activists? While theres a long history of Cabinet members donating to campaigns prior to assuming their roles atop the government, it would be fairly unprecedented for a Cabinet secretary to push policy within the government while her family simultaneously funnels millions to lobby and campaign for those same policies. But the DeVos family isnt shy about using its clout.

Some donors couch their push for influence in the anodyne language of improvement and empowerment. Betsy DeVos is more upfront. My family is the largest single contributor of soft money to the national Republican party, she wrote in a 1997 editorial for Roll Call. I have decided, however, to stop taking offense at the suggestion that we are buying influence. Now I simply concede the point. They are right. We do expect some things in return.

I have decided to stop taking offense at the suggestion that we are buying influence, Betsy DeVos wrote in a 1997 editorial for Roll Call. Now I simply concede the point. They are right. We do expect some things in return.

Its one thing to be an advocate and quite another to be a policymaker in a realm where you have little professional training or personal experiencea charge that DeVos opponents are quick to lob. If confirmed by the Senate, DeVos would be the first secretary of education in at least 30 years without any experience as a government official, school administrator or teacher. Shes not someone with an education backgroundshe never went to a public school, never sent a child to a public school, says Whitmer, who recently announced her candidacy for Michigan governor. Its just stunning that theyd want to export the ugliness [the DeVoses] have brought to the education debate in Michigan and send it to the rest of the nation.

Even so, among the DeVoses skeptics, there are those who strike a hopeful, if cautious, tone. I think Mrs. DeVos could potentially be a really good secretary of education if she allowed parents and school districts to make policy at the local level, says Daniel Quinn, executive director of the Great Lakes Center for Education Research and Practice, a nonprofit that receives a portion of its funding from the National Education Association. But at the same time, Im concerned.

Julie Matuzak, the DeVoses foe from the 2000 voucher fight, disagrees strongly with DeVos appointment but concedes the couple has good intentions. I do believe they have a deep-seated belief in quality education for all children, says Matuzak. They see it as a continuum of public education that includes everythingprivate schools, parochial schools, charters, public schools. But they believe in the market force as the rule of the universe.
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter

Zack Stanton is digital editor of Politico Magazine. Follow him on Twitter: @zackstanton.
Post Mon Jan 16, 2017 4:10 pm 
 View user's profile Send private message  Reply with quote  
El Supremo

Skubick: New gubernatorial candidate Whitmer goes on the attack
By Tim Skubick Published: January 4, 2017, 6:20 pm Updated: January 4, 2017, 6:20 pm

Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window) 536Share on Facebook (Opens in new window)536 Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)

LANSING, Mich (WLNS) Democrat Gretchen Whitmer is one day into her campaign for governor and she is wasting little time taking on Bill Schuette, one of her potential Republican rivals.

What would she tell Bill Schuette to his face today? You failed. Youre one of the failed leaders Im talking about, Whitmer answered.

Admitting thats some rough stuff, she adds the facts are the facts.

Ms. Whitmer is the only announced candidate for governor but she could be running against the Republican attorney general Schuette.

And the former Democratic Senate leader is highly critical of the AGs investigation into the Flint water crisis which could cost taxpayers millions of dollars.

So are the taxpayers getting their monies worth? No, the simple answer is no.

Mr. Schuettes criminal investigation has targeted about a dozen persons connect to the Flint water crisis including two former emergency managers appointed by the governor.

Ms. Whitmer asserts that the lawyers such as Todd Flood are the only winners here.

The only people who are better off from all of that are the lawyers who are getting paid from Bill Schuette, said Whitmer.

In her kitchen on day one of her campaign, she argues Mr. Schuette should have moved quicker to get clean drinking water into the city by using his Consumer Affairs Division created by former attorney general Frank Kelley.

The attorney generals office was good under Frank Kelley but now its been turned into the political arm of Bill Schuette and weve paid the price for that.

But is the attorney general using the probe to advance his political career? Whitmer answers there is a strong case to be made for that.

Ms. Whitmer said shes ready to make that case.

The next race for governor is not until 2018 but obviously Ms. Whitmer is not waiting around to start the attacks.
Post Mon Jan 23, 2017 5:35 pm 
 View user's profile Send private message  Reply with quote  
  Display posts from previous:      
Post new topic Reply to topic

Jump to:  

Last Topic | Next Topic  >

Forum Rules:
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Flint Michigan online news magazine. We have lively web forums

Website Copyright 2010 Flint Talk.com
Contact Webmaster - FlintTalk.com >